The Great E-Mail Marketing Myth

April 18, 2025
Scott Pemberton

Mourn no more.  Reports of the death of e-mail have been greatly exaggerated.

When it makes sense for one of our clients,  we’ll suggest a nurture marketing program, often involving an e-mail newsletter or, more often, a column by-lined by the client. When we do, the client’s response is almost always a variation of “E-mail? I thought that didn’t work anymore.” Followed by: “We want to use social media–you know, Facebook, Twitter.”

Yes, Facebook and Twitter can be key planks in a marketing platform. We use social media, too–again, when it makes sense for the client. We also use snail mail and calling campaigns when they make sense. E-mail does still work when it’s used in the right way for the right reasons.

What are the right reasons?

Our firm serves the business-to-business world. Our clients’ sales are complex, not transactional as in retail, and large. Sales cycles can be long, risk to the buyer is usually high, final decisions will probably be made by committees, not individuals. Credibility and visibility– regular  visibility–become critical.

To build credibility , value must be delivered  during  the sales process and, at least in our minds, direct marketing is clearly part of the sales process. Thought leadership, useful information, and advice become essential. If a reader recognizes your e-mails as valuable, he’ll open them. Regular visibility is a requirement because significant time can elapse between business-to-business purchases. Even if a prospect liked your product or service when she first heard about it, or maybe when you presented, she must  remember  you at the exact time she has a need that your company can satisfy. If not, she’ll likely find someone else.

Regular e-mails will keep you  top of mind when a prospect’s top priority is a problem you can solve. But they must  deliver value.  They can’t be strictly promotional. Our monthly column on sales and marketing,  Productive Insights , is a clear example. Two or three times a year a prospect or client who’s been reading the columns regularly, sometimes for years, calls or e-mails us. All of a sudden he has just the kind of problem we solve: low or slow sales, not enough qualified leads or appointments, and ineffective marketing.

In B-to-B marketing campaigns,  95 percent of participants say they use e-mail, reports a 2015 Direct Marketing Association study. Telephone campaigns make use of e-mail 94 percent of the time. In our experience setting sales appointments and generating leads, clients who use a phone-e-mail combination do enjoy increased response. E-mail is nearly 40 times more effective in acquiring customers (probably “consumer” customers) than Facebook and Twitter combined, according to McKinsey, the consulting firm. (See  Why Marketers Should Keep Sending You E-Mails.)

The “E-mail is dead” mantra , clearly, is not being chanted by professional marketers, including us. Why? Because e-mail works when used at the right time and in the right way.

Scott Pemberton   is a senior consultant at Productive Strategies, a management and marketing firm with expertise in consultative sales training, appointment setting and lead generation, and marketing and marketing communications. He can be reached at  spemberton@productivestrategies.com  or 847-446-0008.

By Phil Krone, President April 28, 2025
Asking the questions that give you the confidence you need to win in sales. 
By Phil Krone, President March 22, 2025
This faith-based not-for-profit achieves 40 percent year-over-year growth for 17 years by applying well-known business principles, one in particular. Why can so few businesses even dream of such growth?
By Phil Krone, President February 17, 2025
Are you selling business to business or business to government or both? There are similarities but also differences that need to be recognized to optimize your results.
By By Phil Krone, President January 17, 2025
Last year after a talk I gave at the Small Business Expo on Business to Business Selling (B2B) , a woman asked for my card because she wanted to meet to tell me about her business and learn more about mine. When we eventually got together she shared that her start-up company’s goal was to console consumers who had suffered the loss of a loved one directly, as she had. But my talk had inspired a new idea: assist funeral homes to improve their services by showing more empathy to their customers who were struggling as she was. I sensed that my talk gave her confidence that, despite the challenges, her business could succeed. What I didn’t realize was that this small assignment for a start-up would eventually have such a big impact on her business as well as an industry. 
By Phillip Krone December 18, 2024
To date we have covered the Sales, Information, Tactical, and Marketing Plan Levels. Although the fifth level is the last to be discussed, it is often what sets a business in motion when it is founded. Today we will illustrate marketing to support a vision by discussing two very successful businesses.
By By Phil Krone, President December 5, 2024
As a reminder, the Five Levels of Marketing are (1) Sales, (2) Information/Data/Analytics, (3) Tactical or Campaign, (4) Marketing or Program, and (5) Vision/Strategic. We’ve explored each of the first three levels in separate columns in August, September, and October. They are available on our website's Productive Insights collection.
By By Phil Krone, President October 16, 2024
Using intelligence from prior levels leads to revenue-building sales campaigns on the ground in real time.
By Phil Krone, President September 16, 2024
Tracking key types of data each month provides insights that can build a highly productive marketing plan.
By Phil Krone, President August 14, 2024
The Five Levels - Sales: Prospecting, qualifying, discovery, presentation, demonstration, proposal writing and closing; Information/Data/Analytics; Tactical or Campaign; Marketing or Program; Vision/Strategic
By Phil Krone, President July 18, 2024
If you believe you have ADHD, you can be more successful by scheduling fewer first meetings and spending that time on more second and third meetings with qualified prospects. For our client, that meant cancelling half the medical CFO conventions his sales rep was planning to attend and investing more time following up with the CFO prospects he had already met. When your discovery is not productive, step back and restart at the point the discussion began to be about whose system is better. That’s an argument you are not going to win. Don’t waste years in prospect meetings in which you ask the same questions every time and get the same answers. Either decide that your product or service isn’t right for this prospect and move on—or broaden your discovery to find a need behind the need. In this hospital case, the hidden need was a fear that because no outside vendors had audited their system they might be in violation of regulations that an outsider would spot right away.
More Posts