Where Do New Product Ideas Come From?

April 18, 2025
Phil Krone

Just about anywhere, of course. But here’s one way to generate them nearly every day.

A simple, straightforward method that can be applied every day is  observation  coupled with “seeing what others don’t see.” Here are two examples from Tom Anderson, Jr., CEO of Digital Check Corporation, the world’s leader in producing check-scanning equipment for banks and their business customers in more than 100 countries. The first instance paid off in the launch of the company nearly sixty years ago that eventually became today’s Digital Check, now in its third generation of family ownership.

Tom Jr. told the story during a “fireside chat” interview with me for about eighty middle-market business owners, CEOs, and presidents in September.*

  Solving a Problem No One Knew Existed

The idea came to Tom’s father, Tom Anderson, Sr., in 1957 while he was relaxing at day’s end with other paper salesmen during an annual industry meeting. They were passing around a new “punch card” from IBM that carried the 35mm image of a large document on what was known as “microfilm.” The combination of image and card was revolutionary because now millions of large paper documents (architectural and engineering drawings, for instance) could be moved much more efficiently and without nearly as much paper.

Tom Sr. noticed that while the card was relatively sturdy the film was not; it would surely suffer abrasion when stacked in a deck and rubbing against other cards also containing microfilm. To make his point, he borrowed a pack of cigarettes (ubiquitous at the time) and instead of lighting up he peeled off the cellophane wrapper and deftly placed it over the 35mm image. He shared his innovation with the other sales reps but didn’t get much reaction. They saw the same card but did  not  recognize the importance and commercial potential that Tom Sr. did.

In less than five minutes the idea for a new-to-the-world product was born. In two years a company to produce patented “suspension” aperture cards was launched by the first generation of a family business that thrives today.

Same Product, New Channel

The second idea also spawned by observation occurred to Tom Anderson, Jr., as he saw the similarities between his company’s check-scanning machines and the Pitney Bowes postage meters.

For two decades the company continued to grow by producing new and upgraded versions of the analog suspension aperture card. Key competitors, in various ways, included giant companies such as IBM, 3M, and Kodak. As the world moved to digital from analog, the company looked for a niche market for the scanning equipment it was developing. Though very small domestically at the time (checks were cleared physically and transported by airplane to clearinghouses for that purpose) check-scanning equipment looked like it would eventually be that market. Good news was that it would likely be too small for the giants to bother with.

So, Digital Check focused on  producing scanners for reading checks and became the world leader in what at the time was a very small market. Always looking for ways to expand Digital Check significantly, Tom Jr., like his father, noticed something. One day while looking at the Pitney Bowes postage meter machine in his office Tom thought “Why can’t a check scanner be to the banking system what a postage machine is to the Post Office?” Nearly every office used postage machines, saving time and energy for the companies and for the Post Office. Why couldn’t check scanners fill that role for banks and their customers?

Unfortunately, despite efforts to create a market, it was an idea whose time had not yet come. But when the 9-11 tragedy grounded all aircraft, the banking system itself nearly ground to a halt, exposing unacceptable vulnerability for the entire economy. Congress then passed legislation that enabled checks to be cleared by using images instead of the physical checks themselves. A new market was born, and Digital Check stood ready to serve an important and immediate need.

Although Digital Check is a client of ours,  we take no credit for any of its product innovations. However, we have developed a process for helping companies think through ways to identify opportunities for new products and develop ideas for those new products. If you would like more information, please contact us att 847-446-0008 Ext. 1 or  pkrone@productivestrategies.com .

*The Presidents’ Symposium, hosted on September 15 by the nonprofit Entrepreneurship Institute at the University of Chicago’s Gleacher Center.

By Phil Krone, President April 28, 2025
Asking the questions that give you the confidence you need to win in sales. 
By Phil Krone, President March 22, 2025
This faith-based not-for-profit achieves 40 percent year-over-year growth for 17 years by applying well-known business principles, one in particular. Why can so few businesses even dream of such growth?
By Phil Krone, President February 17, 2025
Are you selling business to business or business to government or both? There are similarities but also differences that need to be recognized to optimize your results.
By By Phil Krone, President January 17, 2025
Last year after a talk I gave at the Small Business Expo on Business to Business Selling (B2B) , a woman asked for my card because she wanted to meet to tell me about her business and learn more about mine. When we eventually got together she shared that her start-up company’s goal was to console consumers who had suffered the loss of a loved one directly, as she had. But my talk had inspired a new idea: assist funeral homes to improve their services by showing more empathy to their customers who were struggling as she was. I sensed that my talk gave her confidence that, despite the challenges, her business could succeed. What I didn’t realize was that this small assignment for a start-up would eventually have such a big impact on her business as well as an industry. 
By Phillip Krone December 18, 2024
To date we have covered the Sales, Information, Tactical, and Marketing Plan Levels. Although the fifth level is the last to be discussed, it is often what sets a business in motion when it is founded. Today we will illustrate marketing to support a vision by discussing two very successful businesses.
By By Phil Krone, President December 5, 2024
As a reminder, the Five Levels of Marketing are (1) Sales, (2) Information/Data/Analytics, (3) Tactical or Campaign, (4) Marketing or Program, and (5) Vision/Strategic. We’ve explored each of the first three levels in separate columns in August, September, and October. They are available on our website's Productive Insights collection.
By By Phil Krone, President October 16, 2024
Using intelligence from prior levels leads to revenue-building sales campaigns on the ground in real time.
By Phil Krone, President September 16, 2024
Tracking key types of data each month provides insights that can build a highly productive marketing plan.
By Phil Krone, President August 14, 2024
The Five Levels - Sales: Prospecting, qualifying, discovery, presentation, demonstration, proposal writing and closing; Information/Data/Analytics; Tactical or Campaign; Marketing or Program; Vision/Strategic
By Phil Krone, President July 18, 2024
If you believe you have ADHD, you can be more successful by scheduling fewer first meetings and spending that time on more second and third meetings with qualified prospects. For our client, that meant cancelling half the medical CFO conventions his sales rep was planning to attend and investing more time following up with the CFO prospects he had already met. When your discovery is not productive, step back and restart at the point the discussion began to be about whose system is better. That’s an argument you are not going to win. Don’t waste years in prospect meetings in which you ask the same questions every time and get the same answers. Either decide that your product or service isn’t right for this prospect and move on—or broaden your discovery to find a need behind the need. In this hospital case, the hidden need was a fear that because no outside vendors had audited their system they might be in violation of regulations that an outsider would spot right away.
More Posts